3.2.1 People Management

Unit 3.2: Managing People and Operations | A-Level Business Studies

Human Resource (HR) Objectives

Human Resource Objectives: Specific, measurable goals related to the management and development of a business's workforce. These objectives support the overall strategic aims of the organisation.

Key HR Objectives

1. Number and Skills of Employees

Ensuring the business has the right number of employees with the appropriate skills mix to meet current and future demands.

Real-World Example: Amazon

Amazon regularly adjusts its workforce numbers based on demand. During peak periods (Black Friday, Christmas), Amazon hires over 100,000 temporary workers in the UK alone. The company also invests heavily in upskilling programmes like "Career Choice" which pre-pays 95% of tuition for courses in high-demand fields, regardless of whether skills are relevant to Amazon careers.

2. Employee Turnover and Retention

Managing the rate at which employees leave the business (turnover) and implementing strategies to keep valuable staff (retention).

Real-World Example: John Lewis Partnership

John Lewis has historically maintained low turnover rates through its employee ownership model. All permanent staff are "Partners" who own shares in the business and receive annual bonuses based on profits. This creates strong retention, with many employees staying for decades. The retail industry average turnover is around 60%, whilst John Lewis typically maintains rates below 15%.

3. Employee Engagement

The level of commitment, passion, and involvement employees have with their work and the organisation.

Real-World Example: Google (Alphabet Inc.)

Google consistently ranks highly for employee engagement through initiatives like "20% time" (allowing employees to spend 20% of their time on passion projects), extensive perks (free meals, on-site facilities), and flat organisational structures. Gmail and Google News were both developed during 20% time. Their Googlegeist survey measures engagement across all offices globally, with results directly influencing policy changes.

4. Employee Costs

Managing the total expenditure on workforce, including wages, benefits, training, and associated overheads.

Real-World Example: Ryanair

Ryanair maintains one of the lowest cost bases in the airline industry partly through tight control of employee costs. Cabin crew are often employed on temporary contracts with productivity-based pay. This keeps employee costs as a percentage of revenue significantly lower than competitors like British Airways, though it has led to industrial relations challenges and strikes affecting operations.

5. Equality, Diversity, Inclusion and Belonging (EDIB)

Creating a workplace where all employees feel valued, respected, and have equal opportunities regardless of background or characteristics.

Real-World Example: HSBC

HSBC has set specific EDIB objectives including achieving 50% female representation in senior leadership by 2030 and increasing ethnic minority representation in senior roles to 22%. They publish annual diversity reports showing progress. The bank has employee resource groups for various communities and conducts pay gap analyses to ensure equality. HSBC links executive bonuses to achieving diversity targets.

Influences on HR Objectives

Influence Description Example
Corporate Objectives HR objectives must support overall business strategy If Tesco aims to expand internationally, HR must plan for multilingual staff recruitment
Market Conditions Economic climate affects recruitment and wage demands During recession, businesses may set objectives to reduce headcount; in growth periods, aggressive recruitment targets
Technological Change Automation and digitisation change skill requirements High street banks closing branches set objectives to retrain staff for digital customer service roles
Legislation Legal requirements shape HR priorities National Living Wage increases force retailers to set objectives around productivity per employee
Competitor Actions Need to match or exceed rival offerings When Aldi increased starting wages to £12/hour, other supermarkets adjusted their wage objectives
Organisational Culture Company values influence HR priorities Patagonia's environmental values lead to extensive sustainability training objectives for all staff

Human Resource Planning

Human Resource Planning: The process of analysing and forecasting the number of workers and the skills of those workers that will be required by the organisation to achieve its objectives.

Purpose and Value of HR Planning

Recruitment

Planning ensures the business attracts and selects the right talent at the right time.

  • Value: Reduces time-to-hire, improves quality of candidates, ensures continuity of operations
  • Example: NHS England's multi-year planning for nurse recruitment includes international recruitment campaigns to address predicted shortfalls

Training

Identifying future skills needs and developing programmes to equip staff appropriately.

  • Value: Maintains competitive advantage, improves employee satisfaction, reduces need for external recruitment
  • Example: Jaguar Land Rover's £100m training investment to prepare workforce for electric vehicle production

Retention

Planning strategies to keep valuable employees and reduce turnover costs.

  • Value: Preserves organisational knowledge, reduces recruitment costs, maintains customer relationships
  • Example: Deloitte's "Career Breaks" programme allows staff to take 1-6 month sabbaticals to pursue personal goals, improving retention of senior staff

Redeployment

Moving employees to different roles or locations within the organisation.

  • Value: Retains skilled workers, reduces redundancy costs, maintains morale
  • Example: When Marks & Spencer closed stores, they redeployed staff to nearby locations or to online fulfilment centres rather than making redundancies

Redundancy

Planning for ethical and legal workforce reduction when roles are no longer required.

  • Value: Manages costs, ensures legal compliance, protects employer brand
  • Example: BP's 2020 announcement of 10,000 job cuts included extensive consultation, enhanced redundancy packages, and outplacement support to manage the process sensitively

Forms of Employment - Comparison

Full-Time Permanent - Advantages

  • Greater employee commitment and loyalty
  • Easier to build organisational culture
  • Staff develop deep company knowledge
  • Investment in training is worthwhile

Disadvantages

  • Higher costs (benefits, pensions, sick pay)
  • Less flexibility during quiet periods
  • Difficult and expensive to reduce headcount

Example: Waitrose

Uses full-time permanent "Partners" to maintain high service standards.

Part-Time - Advantages

  • Flexibility to match staffing to demand patterns
  • Lower costs per hour worked
  • Access to wider talent pool (parents, students)

Disadvantages

  • Communication challenges with fragmented teams
  • May have less commitment than full-time staff
  • Training costs per hour worked are higher

Example: Tesco

60% of UK workforce is part-time, enabling flexible coverage.

Temporary - Advantages

  • Flexibility for seasonal/project-based demand
  • Easy to adjust workforce size
  • "Trial period" before permanent offers

Disadvantages

  • Lower commitment and loyalty
  • Constant recruitment and training costs
  • May lack company knowledge

Example: Royal Mail

Hires thousands of temporary workers for Christmas period.

Zero-Hours - Advantages

  • Maximum flexibility for uncertain demand
  • Only pay for hours actually worked
  • Retain pool of trained workers

Disadvantages

  • Negative publicity and ethical concerns
  • Workers may seek more secure employment
  • Low engagement and commitment

Example: Sports Direct

Faced criticism for 90%+ zero-hours contracts usage.

Flexible Employment: Work arrangements that deviate from traditional 9-5 office-based employment, including remote working, flexible hours, compressed weeks, job shares.

Significance: Attracts wider talent pool, improves work-life balance and retention, reduces office costs, increases productivity. Post-pandemic, increasingly expected by workers.

Example: Nationwide Building Society's "Working Options" allows most staff to choose their working pattern, leading to closure of office buildings whilst maintaining 85%+ employee satisfaction.

Interrelationship Between HR and Other Business Functions

HR decisions don't exist in isolation. They have significant impacts on and are influenced by all other business functions.

HR ↔ Finance

  • HR impacts Finance: Wage increases and recruitment costs directly affect budgets and profitability
  • Finance impacts HR: Budget constraints limit hiring and training investment
  • Example: Morrisons £12/hour minimum wage added £40m to annual costs

HR ↔ Marketing

  • HR impacts Marketing: Employee knowledge and customer service affect brand reputation
  • Marketing impacts HR: Brand campaigns create demand requiring more staff
  • Example: Apple's premium brand requires highly trained retail staff

HR ↔ Operations

  • HR impacts Operations: Staff skills and motivation affect quality and productivity
  • Operations impacts HR: Production methods determine workforce needs
  • Example: Tesla automation reduced manufacturing workforce whilst increasing maintenance engineer demand

HR ↔ Strategy

  • HR impacts Strategy: Workforce capabilities enable or constrain strategic options
  • Strategy impacts HR: Strategic direction determines HR planning needs
  • Example: Netflix's content strategy required recruiting hundreds of production staff globally

How HR Decisions Affect Business Competitiveness

1. Cost Competitiveness

HR decisions directly impact cost structures and pricing ability.

Example: Primark vs M&S

Primark maintains cost leadership partly through lean staffing and lower wage costs, enabling rock-bottom prices. M&S invests more in staff numbers and training. Primark's HR model supports its competitive strategy of price leadership.

2. Quality and Differentiation

Well-trained, motivated staff deliver superior products and services.

Example: The Ritz London

Can charge £500+ per night partly because of exceptional service from highly trained, well-paid, long-serving staff. HR investment in recruitment, training, and retention enables quality differentiation that justifies premium pricing.

3. Innovation

The right talent and culture drive innovation and adaptability.

Example: Dyson

Dyson's competitiveness depends on continuous innovation. Their HR strategy focuses on recruiting top engineering graduates, investing in 3,500+ UK-based engineers, and creating a culture that encourages experimentation. This HR approach maintains their competitive advantage through constant product innovation.

Purpose and Value of HR Data Measurement

Human Resource Data: Quantitative and qualitative information about the workforce that helps managers make informed decisions about people management.

Key Areas of HR Measurement

1. Employee Engagement

Purpose: Measures extent to which employees are committed, motivated, and willing to go the extra mile.

Value: Engaged employees are 21% more productive. Predicts future turnover problems before they occur.

Example: Nationwide Building Society

Quarterly surveys measure engagement. When contact centre engagement dropped from 78% to 71%, they identified software frustrations, responded with training, and recovered to 76%, preventing 50+ departures.

2. Employee Diversity

Purpose: Measures workforce composition across protected characteristics and representation at all levels.

Value: Diverse teams make better decisions (McKinsey: 36% higher profitability). Legal requirement for 250+ employees.

Example: Lloyds Banking Group

Data showed 49% female overall but only 35% in senior roles. This revealed a "leaky pipeline" problem. HR introduced sponsorship programmes, increasing senior female representation to 38%.

3. Employee Wellbeing

Purpose: Measures physical, mental, and emotional health of employees.

Value: Reduces absence costs (UK average: £658 per employee/year). Wellbeing interventions show 12% productivity gains.

Example: Unilever UK

When "energy scores" dropped 15% in marketing, HR found excessive overtime. Implemented "meeting-free Fridays". Within 3 months, energy recovered, absence dropped 20%, productivity increased despite fewer hours.

Key HR Metrics: Formulas and Calculations

1. Labour Productivity

Labour Productivity = Output / Number of Employees
Or: Revenue (£) / Number of Employees

Measures output per worker. Higher productivity = more efficient workforce.

Example: JD Sports 2023

£10.4bn revenue ÷ 65,000 employees = £160,000 per employee

Compare to Sports Direct (~£130k per employee) to assess relative efficiency.

2. Employee (Labour) Turnover

Employee Turnover % = (Number Leaving / Average Number of Employees) × 100

Measures the rate employees leave. High turnover is costly (recruitment, training, lost productivity).

Example: NHS Trust

Started with 5,000, ended with 5,200, 650 left during year.

Average employees = (5,000 + 5,200) / 2 = 5,100

Turnover = (650 / 5,100) × 100 = 12.7%

At £30k replacement cost per nurse, 650 leavers = £20m in costs.

3. Employee Costs as % of Revenue

Employee Costs % = (Total Employee Costs / Total Revenue) × 100

Shows what proportion of revenue is spent on employees.

Example: Greggs PLC

£1.8bn revenue, £540m employment costs.

(£540m / £1.8bn) × 100 = 30%

For every £1 of sales, 30p goes to employee costs. Typical for food retail (25-35%).

4. Index Numbers

Index Number = (Current Value / Base Year Value) × 100

Allows comparison of how values have changed over time (base year = 100).

Example: Tesco Productivity

2020: £150k per employee (base) = index 100

2023: £172.5k per employee = (£172.5k / £150k) × 100 = index 115

Productivity increased 15% since 2020.

5. Percentage Change

Percentage Change = ((New Value - Original Value) / Original Value) × 100

Example: Amazon Turnover Improvement

2022 turnover: 150%, 2024 turnover: 105%

((105 - 150) / 150) × 100 = -30%

Turnover decreased by 30%. With 50,000 warehouse staff at £5k replacement cost, this 30% reduction saved approximately £112m annually.

Interactive HR Metrics Calculator

Calculate and Analyse HR Data

Practice Scenario: Analysis Challenge

Loading scenario...